1907 Monaco Regatta

Monte Carlo, Monaco, April 1-16, 1907

Select related article . . . Entries for the Monaco Meeting Automobilism Marine Motoring Monaco The Fourth Annual Motor Boat Exhibition and Races at Monaco The Monaco Fiasco The Monaco Motor Boat Races The Racing at Monte Carlo Monaco Records

Monaco

Record Breaking Performances in All Classes Cause Doubts of Accuracy of Course

British Comment Outspoken

The fourth Monaco meeting is over, and for the first time in the history of that greatest event in motorboating, doubt has been thrown upon their accuracy of the times recorded. So great was the lowering of records in all classes, despite generally unfavorable weather conditions, that the impression that the course was short was generally voiced early in the meeting. The English yachting journals, in their accounts of the racing, make comparisons between the records of the recent meeting and those made in past years, and also call attention to the remarkable apparent improvement made by well-known boats, such as La Rapiere II, which had competed in previous years, and whose speeds were pretty well known. The Monaco correspondent of The Motor Boat, London, comments upon the matter as follows:

"Driven their hardest in dead smooth water, the 12-metre racer Panhard-Tellier and the 8-metre La Rapiere II, which finished respectively first and second in the standing mile and flying kilometre not only failed to achieve any faster times than 2 min. 9 sec. and 2 min. 25 sec. for the miles and 1 min. 16 sec. and 1 min. 20 sec. for the kilometre, but demonstrated beyond all doubt that the "world's records" they were alleged to have made during the previous week were wholly fictitious. For these rates of speed, achieved in the favorable circumstances of the flying kilometre--26 1-3 knots and 25 knots respectively--are not only five knots slower than the "world's records" of 31 1-3 and 30 knots each was alleged to have made, but are even slower than Seasick's and not better than F.I.A.T. XIII's times last year.

"This circumstance, and the fact that even fewer boats than last year were qualified to compete in the standing mile and kilometre event--the others not having completed the full course in their class race through disablement and lack of seaworthiness--not only falsify the results of the entire week, but also all the extravagant statements made as to the general improvement in all classes.

"Not only so, but they positively confirm the contention we advance--namely, that the actual course was much shorter than the 50 kilometres it was supposed to measure. According to the information we have obtained from those who were actually aboard competing boats, it appears to have been something under 45 kilometres, or over a quarter of a mile short on each round. Of course, what is done cannot now be undone; the only thing left is to prevent the recurrence of such a lamentable fiasco; one which we prefer to think arose either from incompetence in those entrusted with laying the course or the effect of a heavy ground swell upon insufficient moorings, and not from any tacit "arrangement" to secure réclame for the French trade at the expense of good faith to the sport of motorboating."

The Marine Motor Journal of London, under the heading "All Results Falsified," is even more outspoken, and expresses its opinion as follows:

"To-day has witnessed a continuation of the record-breaking performances, both in the racing and cruiser classes; indeed, without in any way wishing to detract from the splendid performances of the winners, I cannot help wondering if the course is not shorter than it is officially stated to be. This question has been freely discussed ever since La Rapiere II made her sensational run in the small racing class, it seeming impossible that any amount of tuning up could account for the enormous improvement in her form, though I purposely refrained from making any comment of this nature at the time. Still, the continuance of absolutely phenomenal records in practically every race makes it at least desirable that the course should be remeasured. No one, of course, doubts the good faith of the Racing Committee, who are all of them the soul of honor, but it is at least possible that some of the marks may have dragged their moorings, and re-measurement should at least set all doubts at rest."

The remarkable improvement in speed which has given rise to these suspicions is shown by a comparison of the records of this year with those of a year ago. In the 8-metre class, the winner in 1906 was Antoinette IV, with a speed of 23.34 knots. This year the event was won by La Rapiere II at a speed of 28.95 knots. In the 8 to 12-metre class, Yarrow Napier (now Flying Fish) won at the rate of 13.44 knots; this year's winner, Panhard-Tellier is credited with 29.73 knots. In the Championship of the Sea, Delahaye made 23.12 knots in 1906, and Panhard-Tellier 30.41 knots in 1907.

The cruisers show a proportionate advance in speed. In the class up to 6½ metres Mendelssohn made 12.95 knots in 1906, and Capoulon III made 17.25 knots in 1907. In the class from 6½ to 8 metres, Excelsior VIII made 11.59 knots in 1906, and Mais-Je-Vais-Piguer made 16.44 in 1907. In the class from 8 to 12 metres, Calypso made 18.33 knots in 1906, and Ulysses 20.61 knots in 1907. In the 12 to 18 metres class, Pampa made 13.22 knots in 1906, and Lorraine 1121.74 knots in 1907. The complete summary of the meeting follows (all speeds in knots):

FIRST DAY, APRIL 8
Class I -- Cruisers up to 6½ metres. Distance 50 kilometres (31.05 miles). Prize, 7,000 f. ($1,400)
Name		Length			Time		Speed
Capoulon III		21 ft. 9 in.			1.35.55
Nautilus Mutel I		"			1.36.11
Gamine		"			1.39.28
Champagne		"			1.51.56
Lanturlu III		"			1.58.19
C. B. II		"			1.59.47
Joliette III		"			2.38.30
Lanturlu II		"			2.40.07
Fleur d'Helice		"			2.55.52
Class I -- Racers up to 8 metres
Course, 50 kilometres Prize, 9,000 f. ($1,800)
La Rapiere II		26 ft. 3 in.			0.55.55		28.95
Fiat XV		"			0.57.56		28.1
Seasick		"			1.00.50		26.16
Mouvette		"			1.59.00
SECOND DAY, APRIL 8
Class II -- Cruisers 6½ to 8 metres Distance, 50 kilometres
Mais-Je-Vais-Piquer		26 ft. 3 in.			1.38.24		16.44
Dalifol-Petroleum		21 ft. 7 in.			Not required to finish
Nautilus B. V. Jacqueline		26 ft. 3 in.			Disabled
THIRD DAY, APRIL 9
Class IV -- Cruisers 17 to 18 metres. Distance, 50 kilometres
Lorraine		46 ft. 6 in.			1.14.21		21.7
All 'Erta		40 ft.			1.22.26		19.6
Florentia III		40 ft.			1.24.48		19.0
Hydroplane Class, 10 Kilometres
Obus-Nautilus					18.24		17.5
Motogodille-Glisseur					Withdrawn
Glisseur-de-Lambert					Disabled
Class II -- Racers 8 to 18 metres. Distance, 50 kilometres
Panhard-Tellier		40 ft.			0.54.27		29.2
Mercedes D. L.		60 ft.			1.42.56		15.7
Daimler II		40 ft.			Withdrawn
Daimler III		40 ft.			"
Flving Fish		39 ft. 6 in.			"
New-Trefle		36 ft. 3 in.			"
Jeanette		40 ft.			"
FOURTH DAY, APRIL 10
Class III -- Cruisers 80 to 12 metres. Distance, 50 kilometres
Ulysses		26 ft. 3 in.			1.18.23		20.61
Galinari II		"			1.22.10
Adele		"			1.24.25
Le Sec		"			1.27.36
Vedette Boats, Distance, 50 kilometres
B. I. Jacqueline III	25 ft.			2.30.12
Nautilus B. V. Jacqueline	"			2.33.40
Nautilus-Mutel	"			2.49.25
Marie Brizard	"			3.04.16
C. B. I	"			3.10.08
Arion-Despujols	"			3.16.36
Martini-Megevet	"			3.21.21
Motobloc	"			3.29.04
FIFTH DAY, APRIL 11
Championship of the Sea
Open to boats which have completed any race of 50 kilometres
Distance, 200 kilometres (124.22 miles)
Panhard-Tellier	40 ft.			3.33.04		30.41
All 'Erta	40 ft.			4.46.24		22.60
Ulysses	26 ft. 3 in.			4.59.49		21.58
Flyng Fish	39 ft. 6 in.			5.14.13		20.62
Adele				5.16.03		20.51
Mercedes D. L.	60 ft.			7.55.00
SIXTH DAY, APRIL 14
Handicap for racers, 50 kilo	Start			Finish		Time
Mercedes D. L.	10.30.00			12.06.27		1.36.27
Flying Fish	10.53.00			12.08.36		1.15.02
Seasick	11.00.00			12.15.02		1.15.02
Handicap for cruisers, 50 kilo
Ressac	8.00.00			11.59.02		3.59.02
Roi d'Ys	8.40.00			12.06.10		3.26.10
Pilote 1	8.48.00			12.08.29		3.20.29
Adele	10.44.00			12.09.19		1.25.19
Lally	9.36.00			12.09.48		2.33.48
Standing mile and flying kilometre trials
Cruisers under 8 metres	Mile			Kilometer		Total
Nautilus-Mutel	3.49			2.13		6.02
Nihil	3.55			2.12		6.07
Cruisers over 8 metres
All 'Erta	2.52			1.35		4.27
Despujols-Mutel	2.52			1.42		4.35
Nautilus	2.57			1.44		4.42
Racers under 8 metres
La Rapiere	2.23 2/5			1.25 1/5		3.48 1/5
Racers over 8 metres
Panhard-Tellier	2.19 2/5			1.31 1 /5		3.33 1 /5
Flying Fish	2.43 3/5			1.31 1/5		4.14 4/5
Standing mile and flying kilometre finals
Cruisers
All Erta	2.45		1.44			4.29
Despujols-Mutel	3.28		2.00			5.28
Nautilus-Mutel	3.44		2.18			6.02
Racers
Panhard-Tellier	2.09 4/5		1.16 2/5			3.26 1 /5
La Rapiere II	2.25		1.20 2/5			3.45 2/5
Flying Fish	2.38 4/5		1.35 3/5			4.11 2/5
SEVENTH DAY, APRIL 15
Handicap for cruisers 18.75 metres
Won by Ulysses Time 31 m. 26 s. Second Nautilus B. V. Jacqueline II Time 37 m. 24 s. Third Nautilus-Mutel Time 38 m. II s. Handicap for racers 18.75 metres Won by Flying Fish Time 46 m. 28 s.

 

(Transcribed from The Motor Boat, May 10, 1907, pp. 16-20)

[Thanks to Greg Calkins for help in preparing this page. --LF]